Casey Cagle and Senate Bills with Possible Constitutionality Issues

On Wednesday, March 25, 2009, around 11:50 or so the Senate was discussing a proposed Amendment to HB 160, the Super Speeder bill that a few minutes later passed the Senate. This amendment would have forced the money generated to be used to fund a statewide trauma network, yet according to the State Constitution, such determinations must be made by referendum and cannot be legislated by the General Assembly. During the debate, Senator Preston Smith challenged the constitutionality of this amendment, and asked Casey Cagle as President of the Senate to make a determination.

Cagle’s response was that as Lt Governor and President of the Senate, he did not have the authority to rule on the constitutionality of a bill before the Senate, nor any proposed amendments to this bill. He noted – correctly – that these decisions are the sole responsibility of the Supreme Court of the State of Georgia.

And yet, there is a problem with this.

You see, there was another amendment to another bill on Monday, almost 48 hours to the minute prior to the Lt Gov making these remarks about not having the authority to rule on constitutional issues.

On this one, it was Steve Thompson’s Amendment 2 to HR 206. While I don’t remember the exact substance of it, and I hope Sen. Thompson may be able to provide it, it DID appear to me to be two separate questions. Per the GA Constitution, a ballot referendum must have exactly one question and one question only.

Cagle declared the amendment unconstitutional and thus out of order.

Something that he admitted not quite 48 hours later was not within his authority as Lt Governor.

And this man, who clearly doesn’t understand the powers of the office he has held for just over two years now, wants to move up to the highest elected office in this Great State?

I think he needs to more fully learn the Constitutional limits and powers of the office he already holds first.

Advertisements

6 Responses

  1. […] it was intentional or not, it seems like people are setting up Cagle to fail. On Wednesday, March 25, 2009, around 11:50 or so the Senate was discussing a proposed Amendment to […]

  2. It’s always amusing to note the double speak our politicians often engage in. They often say one thing then do another. Cagle just slipped up by doing the two so close together.

  3. Yeah, honestly I probably wouldn’t have caught it – and certainly probably would not have been able to report it – has there been a month or so between the two.

    But doing them on back to back Legislative Days? Come on! ANYONE who is watching them – either inside the Gold Dome or via the live feed or even viewing the live feed download at another time – is going to pick up on that! That ‘traditional’ media didn’t – indeed, evidently I was the first BLOGGER to break this story – is very telling.

    BTW: Do you know of a free ASF/WMV converter? If I can find one, I can put the relevant sections of video on youtube as proof.

  4. Sorry, I’m lost on that one. I’ve never had the need or desire to do anything like that before, so I’ve never even looked.

  5. @ PeachPundit, If Cagle fails, Cagle fails on his own and doesn’t need help doing that. Is what happens when you are a snake in the grass.. While all may look glorious on the outside, “You can’t judge a book by looking at the cover”…

  6. I agree with TOM!!
    They often say one thing then do another. Cagle just slipped up by doing the two so close together.:
    This is in ANY politician…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: